James Neujahr

Convicted of 20 counts of CSAM / Class D Felony

The former band director pled no contest to the 20 counts.

Sentencing Hearing

***These notes are meant to serve as a record of what happened during
Neujahr’s sentencing hearing. This is not a judgment on the author’s
part. Any quotes noted here are as was said verbatim. Everything else
around the quotes is my phrasing. Also, there will be graphic
descriptions of what was viewed in the CSAM, known as Child Sexual
Abuse Materials, used to be referred to and can still be referred to as
“child porn”, depending on the state legal vocabulary and local
vocabulary. Anyone can be a victim. If you or someone you know may
be a victim, please reach out to National Center for Missing & Exploited
Children at https://www.missingkids.org/home. ***

Prosecution said:

The prosecutor began by noting that as a term, “child porn” is poor because
children can’t consent. He then said “CSAM” is better because it encapsulates
what children go through when this material is made, produced, and viewed –
“Child Sexual Abuse Material”.

They then go on to note that this started because the defendant did 2 uploads containing a total of 3 images.

Referencing the initial report made, Neujahr had admitted to the officer to being aroused to first teens, then children of younger ages. They searched his devices and of the over 10,000 images found 2878 known victims.

There were so many images they found that the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children required 2 separate uploads (max is 10,000).

Defense said:

The defense attorney said this was a difficult case.
No evidence that Neujahr looked at each individual image.

The idea that Neujahr looked at each CSAM image from the mass download he did defies logic.
He emphasized that Neujahr never once blamed alcohol.

Later, he referenced page 25 of the presentencing report where Neujahr “accepts responsibility”.
He also emphasized the amount of support Neujahr had from the community, including a letter from a parent of a former student and the letter from the current principal of FVL

He also emphasized that Neujahr had a good career that he will never be able to return to.

Judge said:

“These are real children and the community needs to hear that”.
Also “the children need to be the center”.

She also recognized that it is easy to become jaded about cases like these, thinking that “oh just another child porn case” – “there is nothing normal about these charges”.
“We can’t talk like that and expect the community to not act different.”
She said she noted the tears shed by each child while they were being abused in each video.

There were “2 truths” she had to weigh: considering both the character of the defendant and the victims impacted.
She said she is being urged by family and friends that Neujahr should be seen as “more than the worst thing he’s ever done” – there’s still a theme here of him being a victim.

She emphasized again that it’s real children being assaulted, having things inserted into them.

Sentencing recommendation:

10-15 years / image, to be served concurrently,
with extended supervision and to follow all registered sex offender requirements.

Sentencing recommendation:

3 year per charge, served concurrently, in addition to monitoring. He also requested that Neujahr be allowed contact with his grandchildren.

Neujahr’s Statement:

He said he knew he had forgivingness granted to him by his Savior.
“even though I’ve done terrible things.”
“forgiveness and salvation are mine not by what I’ve done”, but “solely and completely what Christ has done for me”.

The Judge Determined

Neujahr will serve a minimum of 7 years of
prison, and then after prison undergo 7 years of extended supervision.

“As much as I, in the past, felt a disconnect to these children, and in a way, they didn’t seem real, the impact statements prove that they are indeed real human beings who need and deserve our respect, love, and protection.”

    Neujahr at his sentencing hearing – quote from his apology featured both here and to the left.

    What to know…

    • Neujahr has to register as a sex offender.
    • No contact with anyone under 18 years of age without prior agent approval.
    • No access to the internet without prior agent approval.

    More to read below.

    Join 900+ subscribers

    Stay in the loop with everything you need to know.